Updated 21 October 2026 · SmokeCue Editorial Team

Top cigar shops and cigar brands compared

15 brands, ranked on the terms we checked.

Offers you can use come first, then value, then score, so a lower score can lead.

What matters most

BrandScoreCigar originsProductsFree shippingFree shipping threshold Read moreSupport channels
  • 1

    Cigars.com

    Top pick

    Best for: Shoppers who value cigar centered browsing from home

    8.0
    Not listed
    Not listed
    Not listed
    Not listed
    Loyalty scheme
    Yes
    Free shipping threshold
    Not listed
    Support channels
    Not listed
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Adult smokers enjoy exploring cigar options before lighting up.
    • Buyers check format, strength and packaging before ordering.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Buyers under the legal age for tobacco products
    • Shoppers wanting a general smoke shop with many unrelated categories
    Markets
    United States
    Legal entity
    Tabacalera USA, Inc.
    Read review
  • 2

    Atlantic Cigar

    Top pick

    Best for: A broad cigar and accessory store with free delivery above $99.

    9.2
    Nicaragua +4
    Premium cigars +4
    $99
    Email, Phone
    Loyalty scheme
    Yes
    Free shipping threshold
    $99
    Not listed
    Support channels
    Email, Phone
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Readers who want a members club that adds savings on most lines, along with offers and specials.
    • Buyers who like choosing between named houses such as Padron, Arturo Fuente and Montecristo before committing to a single maker.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Buyers hunting cigars from countries the store does not draw on, as the sourcing list closes at nicaragua, dominican republic, honduras and more.
    • Anyone who needs longer than 14 days from receipt to decide.
    Cigar origins
    Nicaragua, Dominican republic, Honduras, and 2 more
    Products
    Premium cigars, Machine made cigars, Cigar samplers, and 2 more
    Markets
    United States, Canada, China, and 3 more
    Legal entity
    Atlantic Cigar Company
    Headquarters
    United States
    Read review
  • 3

    Escobar Cigars

    Top pick

    Best for: US cigar buyers whose baskets clear $100.

    9.2
    Nicaragua, Honduras, Other
    Premium cigars +2
    $100
    Email, Phone, Help centre
    Loyalty scheme
    Yes
    Free shipping threshold
    $100
    Not listed
    Support channels
    Email, Phone, Help centre
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Regular shoppers, as the VIP programme pays points and rewards on every order placed.
    • Readers who like a blended cigar, since the Habano pairs an Ecuadorian wrapper with Nicaraguan and Honduran filler.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Readers living outside the US, since orders travel domestically.
    • Anyone shopping for vapes or nicotine pouches, as this is a cigar counter.
    Cigar origins
    Nicaragua, Honduras, Other
    Products
    Premium cigars, Cigar samplers, Cigar accessories
    Markets
    United States
    Legal entity
    Puros Privados
    Headquarters
    United States
    Read review
  • 4

    BnB Tobacco

    Top pick

    Best for: US cigar and pouch buyers who want a wholesaler's range with rewards and auto-ship orders.

    8.9
    Dominican republic +4
    Premium cigars +7
    $199
    Email, Phone, Chat +1
    Loyalty scheme
    Yes
    Free shipping threshold
    $199
    Not listed
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Hemp and CBD buyers who want lab results published before they order.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Readers who want one manufacturer's full range, as BnB Tobacco is a store carrying cigars from several countries.
    Support channels
    Email, Phone, Chat, and 1 more
    Cigar origins
    Dominican republic, Nicaragua, Honduras, and 2 more
    Products
    Premium cigars, Machine made cigars, Cigarillos, and 5 more
    Markets
    United States, Canada
    Legal entity
    BnB Tobacco, Inc.
    Headquarters
    United States
    Founded
    2009
    • Cost8.5
    • Offer9.5
    • Trust8.7
    Read review
  • 5

    Buitrago Cigars

    Top pick

    Best for: US buyers who want cigars, rolling papers and humidors in one basket with free delivery above $199.

    8.7
    Dominican republic
    Premium cigars +6
    $199
    Email, Phone
    Loyalty scheme
    Yes
    Free shipping threshold
    $199
    Not listed
    Support channels
    Email, Phone
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Regular smokers who would rather set a schedule and let the cigar club subscription handle refills.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Shoppers living outside the US, since the documented delivery policy covers domestic orders.
    • Readers who expect the entry price in the catalogue to describe a cigar.
    Cigar origins
    Dominican republic
    Products
    Premium cigars, Machine made cigars, Cigarillos, and 4 more
    Markets
    United States
    Headquarters
    United States
    Founded
    2015
    • Cost8.5
    • Offer9.2
    • Trust8.0
    Read review
  • 6

    JR Cigar

    Top pick

    Best for: US cigar buyers who want humidors, lighters and pipe products in the same order as their cigars.

    8.5
    Dominican republic +5
    Premium cigars +8
    Not listed
    Email, Phone, Help centre
    Loyalty scheme
    Yes
    Free shipping threshold
    Not listed
    Support channels
    Email, Phone, Help centre
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Cigar smokers who keep humidors, lighters and cases on the same order as their cigars, since storage and flame pieces sit beside the cigar shelf.
    • Repeat buyers willing to join the loyalty programme and let every order earn points and rewards.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Anyone living outside the United States at a civilian address, since the shipping arrangement covers consumers in the country and APO/FPO military addresses.
    • Fans after an origin outside the region filter, who would have to ask the help desk instead of narrowing the list by country.
    Cigar origins
    Dominican republic, Nicaragua, Honduras, and 3 more
    Products
    Premium cigars, Machine made cigars, Cigarillos, and 6 more
    Markets
    United States
    Legal entity
    JRCigars.com, Inc.
    Headquarters
    United States
    Read review
  • 7

    Smoke Inn

    Top pick

    Best for: Smokers wanting online ordering with in person lounge visits

    8.0
    Not listed
    Premium cigars, Humidors +1
    Not listed
    Phone
    Loyalty scheme
    Yes
    Free shipping threshold
    Not listed
    Support channels
    Phone
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • US shoppers ordering cigars online for home delivery
    • Visitors near South Florida seeking an in person lounge

    Look elsewhere if

    • Shoppers seeking products outside cigars and cigar gear
    Products
    Premium cigars, Humidors, Cigar accessories
    Markets
    United States
    Founded
    1996
    Read review
The price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read moreWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read moreCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more

Picks by need

  • Best forShoppers who value cigar centered browsing from home

    Cigars.com

    Online cigar retailer.

  • Best forSmokers wanting online ordering with in person lounge visits

    Smoke Inn logoSmoke Inn

    Cigar shop selling premium cigars, humidors and cigar accessories online and in store.

Keep comparing