Updated · SmokeCue Editorial Team

How to choose cigar shops and cigar brands

Compare cigar shops and cigar brands on range, cigar origins, samplers and subscriptions, storage and delivery, return windows and support channels.

Shop or brand

You can buy cigars online from two kinds of seller. A cigar shop carries many makers, so you can compare lines, sizes and origins in one place. A cigar brand sells its own blends directly, which gives you its full range and its own terms. Both can work well. The right choice depends on whether you want variety or already know the cigars you like. A cigar shop may also sell humidors, cutters and lighters, which helps if you are starting out.

Cigars are for adults only, and an age check is part of ordering and often of delivery too. You can compare the shops and brands side by side on the cigar ranking.

Range: premium, machine-made and cigarillos

Premium cigars are rolled by hand from long-filler tobacco. Machine-made cigars use shorter filler and are made in larger runs. Cigarillos are small, thin cigars for a shorter session. A shop that covers all three gives you more room to explore, while a brand will focus on its own lines.

Within each line, compare size and shape, the wrapper leaf and the body, from mild to full. Product pages should list these clearly so you can match a new cigar to one you already enjoy.

Ring gauge and length set how long a cigar lasts and how it draws. If you are new to cigars, a smaller size is a sensible first step before you commit to a box.

Origins

Origin shapes flavor. Nicaragua, the Dominican Republic and Honduras are the main sources in many catalogs, with some cigars made in the United States and elsewhere. If you have a favorite origin, check that the shop stocks a good spread from it. If you want to explore, a shop with several origins makes side-by-side tasting easier.

The wrapper leaf matters as well. A light Connecticut-shade wrapper tends to give a milder profile, while a dark maduro wrapper tends to taste richer. Product pages should name the wrapper, binder and filler origins.

Samplers and subscriptions

A sampler groups several different cigars in one box so you can try lines without buying a full box of each. A subscription sends a selection on a schedule. Both are useful when you are still finding your taste, and samplers make it easy to compare origins side by side. Check how a subscription can be paused or cancelled, and whether you can see the selection before it ships.

How Holt's Cigar, Atlantic Cigar and BnB Tobacco differ

Holt’s Cigar is a US shop founded in 1898. It carries premium and machine-made cigars, cigarillos, samplers and cigar subscriptions, plus humidors and accessories, with origins across the Dominican Republic, Honduras, Nicaragua and the US. It allows 30 days for returns and offers email, live chat, phone and a help center. Atlantic Cigar is a shop that ships to the US and Canada and to several markets in Asia. It stocks premium and machine-made cigars, samplers and humidors from Nicaragua, the Dominican Republic, Honduras and more. Its return window is 14 days, and support runs by email and phone.

BnB Tobacco is a US and Canada shop founded in 2009. Next to cigars and samplers it sells pipe tobacco and pipes. It offers a subscription and discreet shipping, and you can reach it by email, phone, live chat or a help center.

Holt’s Cigar and BnB Tobacco suit buyers who want a broad shop with several ways to reach support. Atlantic Cigar suits buyers who need delivery to Canada or Asia.

Storage, delivery and returns

Cigars need stable humidity. A good shop keeps stock in a humidor and packs orders to protect them in transit. Plan for storage at home before a larger order: the guide to humidors and cigar accessories covers what to look for. Watch delivery in very hot or cold weather. Return windows differ, and opened boxes usually cannot go back, so read the terms first.

Carriers often ask for an adult signature on delivery, so plan to be home or choose a pickup point. In the US, rules on shipping tobacco vary by state, so check that the shop delivers to your state before you build a basket.

How to shortlist

Use these steps to narrow your list before you commit to an order.

  • Decide between a multi-brand shop and buying from a brand.
  • Check that the shop delivers to your state or country.
  • Look for the origins, sizes and samplers you want.
  • Compare return windows, subscription terms and support channels.
  • Read the reviews, then compare on the cigar ranking.

See the full ranking: Top cigar shops and cigar brands compared →

Sources