Buitrago CigarsNo. 9 of 15 in cigar shops and cigar brands
8.7Best for: US buyers who want cigars, rolling papers and humidors in one basket with free delivery above $199.
- Free shipping threshold
- $199
- Loyalty scheme
- Yes
- Markets
- United States
- Headquarters
- United States
Alternatives to Buitrago Cigars
- Cigars.com8.0
Our verdict
Buitrago Cigars suits US adult smokers who want cigars, rolling papers and humidors gathered in one store instead of split across makers. It has traded since 2015, and free delivery starts at $199, which rewards the larger baskets a steady cigar household tends to place.
Fits you if
- US adults who want handmade and machine-made cigars alongside rolling papers and humidors.
- Regular smokers who would rather set a schedule and let the cigar club subscription handle refills.
- Bigger baskets, since free delivery starts at $199.
Look elsewhere if
- Shoppers living outside the US, since the documented delivery policy covers domestic orders.
- Readers who expect the entry price in the catalogue to describe a cigar.
- Buyers who prefer a maker’s own site to a store, and want to see how Atlantic Cigar approaches the same shelf space.
Key facts
- Free shipping threshold
- $199
- Price from
- $3.28
- Loyalty scheme
- Yes
- Markets
- United States
- Products
- Premium cigars, Machine made cigars, Cigarillos, Cigar samplers, Cigar subscriptions, Humidors, Cigar accessories
- Cigar origins
- Dominican republic
- Materials
- Glass, Metal, Hemp paper, Unbleached paper
- Headquarters
- United States
- Founded
- 2015
- Support channels
- Email, Phone
- Official website
- buitragocigars.com
- Profiles
- Trustpilot
Facts checked 1 October 2026, 6 sources
Pros and cons
Pros
- One basket covers premium cigars, machine made cigars, cigarillos and more, so the smoke, its storage and its gear leave together.
- Accessory stock covers glass, metal, hemp paper and more, putting rolling materials and humidor materials in the same cart.
- Free delivery applies from $199, which suits anyone ordering for more than one smoke.
- Based in the United States and trading since 2015, the store brings a settled place to the Miami cigar trade.
Cons
- Free shipping starts at $199, so smaller baskets pay for delivery.
- The entry price of $3.28 sits on a rolling paper pack rather than a cigar, so it tells a buyer little about what a smoke costs in the same basket.
- The cigar club subscription rewards a steady order rhythm, which does little for occasional buyers.
Who runs it
Buitrago Cigars is a US storefront that began trading in 2015, run from its base in the United States by partners who said they set out to change how cigars reach buyers. The shop keeps a cigar club subscription alongside its shelves for customers who buy on a schedule, which says who it expects back. When an order needs a person, support runs on email and phone, and the store invites buyers to use either route rather than filling in a form and waiting on a queue. The pattern is a seller organised around repeat business, with the club, the delivery threshold and the contact routes all pointed at the same buyer.
Questions
What kinds of cigars does Buitrago Cigars sell?
Buitrago Cigars is a store rather than a single maker, so the shelves mix handmade cigars, cigarillos and a cigar subscription, with rolling papers, humidors and accessories alongside. One checkout covers the smoke and the gear, which suits buyers who would rather not split an order across several makers.
Is there free shipping?
Free shipping applies to qualifying orders above $199, and orders travel by UPS Ground, USPS Priority Mail and USPS Ground Advantage. In practice the threshold rewards larger baskets, so anyone buying a single accessory should expect to cover delivery unless another offer picks it up.
Which countries does it ship to?
The documented shipping policy covers the United States, and the store runs from its base in the United States. Buyers outside that country sit outside the stated policy, so overseas shoppers should speak to the store before ordering, since tobacco crossing borders follows local rules the shop does not spell out.
What do the rolling papers and humidors come in?
Rolling papers sit at $3.28 for the RAW Classic pack the site lists. The gear pages cover unbleached paper, hemp paper and glass, so rolling materials and humidor materials appear under the same roof. Buyers chasing a low figure will find it in papers rather than cigars.
Is there a loyalty club?
A cigar club subscription sits alongside the shop, so regular buyers can set a schedule and let refills clear the $199 free delivery mark each time. It suits households that smoke at a steady rhythm, and gives occasional buyers less reason to join than the store’s standing customers.
Can I reach a person about an order?
The team answers by phone and email, so a bundle order, a club refill or a parcel that arrives damaged does not have to sit in a ticket queue. Running as a store means those practical questions reach the people who handle the orders day to day.
How long has the store been trading?
Buitrago Cigars has been trading since 2015, which puts it ahead of the flash-in-the-pan storefronts that open and close between one delivery season and the next. Buyers who weigh whether a shop will still answer questions after an order goes wrong can read that history as part of the decision.
Sources
- buitragocigars.com checked 1 October 2026
Backs: Free shipping threshold, Loyalty scheme, Products, Brand or store
“Free shipping is available on qualifying orders over $199”
- buitragocigars.com/about-us checked 1 October 2026
Backs: Founded, Headquarters, Support channels
“Established in 2015 by three passionate partners, Buitrago Cigars embarked on a mission to revolutionize the cigar industry”
- buitragocigars.com/handmade-cigars checked 1 October 2026
Backs: Cigar origins
“Made in the Dominican Republic, our ACID cigarillos come in cartons of 10 individually packaged infused cigars”
- buitragocigars.com/raw checked 1 October 2026
Backs: Materials
“Shop authentic RAW Rolling Papers. Find RAW Organic Hemp & Classic papers, pre-rolled cones, and tips in all sizes”
- buitragocigars.com/raw checked 1 October 2026
Backs: Price from
“RAW Classic SuperNatural Rolling Paper 12 Inch 1Ct ... MSRP: $3.28”
- buitragocigars.com/shipping-policy checked 1 October 2026
Backs: Markets
“We ship via UPS Ground ,USPS Priority Mail and USPS Ground Advantage”
Compiled from 6 source pages, checked 1 October 2026. We did not open an account.
