Atlantic CigarNo. 4 of 15 in cigar shops and cigar brands
9.2Best for: A broad cigar and accessory store with free delivery above $99.
- Free shipping threshold
- $99
- Loyalty scheme
- Yes
- Legal entity
- Atlantic Cigar Company
- Headquarters
- United States
Alternatives to Atlantic Cigar
- Cigars.com8.0
Our verdict
Atlantic Cigar suits buyers who want cigars, samplers, humidors and accessories all in a single store, and orders above $99 ship free. Run by Atlantic Cigar Company out of the United States, it keeps a tight returns window and a short list of shipping countries.
Fits you if
- Readers who want a members club that adds savings on most lines, along with offers and specials.
- US and overseas shoppers who push a single order past $99 to get free delivery.
- Buyers who like choosing between named houses such as Padron, Arturo Fuente and Montecristo before committing to a single maker.
Look elsewhere if
- Buyers hunting cigars from countries the store does not draw on, as the sourcing list closes at nicaragua, dominican republic, honduras and more.
- Anyone who needs longer than 14 days from receipt to decide.
Key facts
- Free shipping threshold
- $99
- Loyalty scheme
- Yes
- Markets
- United States, Canada, China, Japan, Taiwan, Malaysia
- Products
- Premium cigars, Machine made cigars, Cigar samplers, Humidors, Cigar accessories
- Cigar origins
- Nicaragua, Dominican republic, Honduras, United states, Other
- Departments
- Cigars, Lighters and torches, Storage and stash
- Materials
- Silicone, Metal
- Return window
- 14 days
- Legal entity
- Atlantic Cigar Company
- Headquarters
- United States
- Support channels
- Email, Phone
- Official website
- atlanticcigar.com
- Profiles
Facts checked 1 October 2026, 6 sources
Pros and cons
Pros
- Unopened goods can come back within 14 days in original condition, a stated window rather than a vague promise.
- A members club hands members extra savings on most products along with exclusive offers and specials.
Cons
- Orders under $99 still pay a delivery charge, so a small sampler or accessory order costs more to arrive.
- The returns window is 14 days from receipt, which is tight for buyers still comparing humidors or sampler sets.
Who runs it
Atlantic Cigar is run by Atlantic Cigar Company, with its mailing address at a Norristown, Pennsylvania street in the United States. A named legal entity and a published postal address are the first things to match when a shipment needs tracing or a return needs a destination, because both sit with the store itself rather than on a marketplace listing. Support runs through email and phone, so a reader can pick an online form or a spoken call, one of them toll free and another a direct local line, rather than being left with a ticket number. Both routes stay open to questions about an order still in progress and about one that has already arrived, which matters when a box needs explaining or a return needs a destination written out. For shoppers comparing who stands behind a box of cigars, the company name, the country on the address and the ways to make contact together answer most of the early questions before any money changes hands.
Questions
How much does shipping cost, and when is it free?
Standard ground shipping carries a flat charge, and orders over $99 ship free, so a larger basket pays nothing extra to deliver. Orders inside the US placed before the afternoon cut-off are the ones most often sent the same working day. Small orders below the threshold still carry the fee, which is why adding a sampler or an accessory often pays better than ordering it alone.
How long do I have to send an order back?
Returns are accepted within 14 days of receipt, and goods have to come back in original condition. The clock starts when the order reaches you rather than when it is placed, so a slow delivery eats into the time left. Anything opened or used is harder to send back, so readers who prefer to smoke before deciding should plan for that.
Is there a membership or rewards club?
The store runs a VIP Members Club, where membership brings extra savings on most products along with exclusive offers and specials. Shipping terms are the same either way: orders above $99 ship free for members and non-members alike. The club stacks discounts onto the regular range rather than opening a separate set of products.
Which countries can I order from?
Orders are accepted from 6 countries including the United States, Canada and China only, so buyers outside that list cannot check out at all. US domestic orders placed before the afternoon cut-off are treated as the quickest route, while the other listed countries go through a separate international ordering route. If you are outside those countries, checking this before ordering saves a failed checkout.
Whose cigars do you actually stock?
The store is run by Atlantic Cigar Company and carries well known houses such as Padron, Arturo Fuente, Montecristo, Romeo y Julieta and ACID, alongside everyday bundled brands. Because several makers sit side by side, sampler boxes are a practical way to compare blends before committing to a full box of one.
What accessories are on offer alongside the cigars?
The accessories run to ashtrays, cutters, cases and humidification devices, with the pages stating plainly what each item is built from. A metal double blade cutter is described as well designed and made to last, and a metal ashtray is put forward for outdoor use. Adding one of these to a cigar order can push the basket past $99 and take the delivery charge off.
Who is behind the storefront?
The business behind the storefront is Atlantic Cigar Company, and its mailing address sits in the United States at a Norristown, Pennsylvania street. Having a named company and a published postal address makes it easier to check who stands behind a shipment when something needs tracing or a return needs a destination.
Sources
- atlanticcigar.com checked 1 October 2026
Backs: Loyalty scheme
“VIP Members Club - Extra Savings On Most Products, Exclusive Offers & Specials”
- atlanticcigar.com/accessories checked 1 October 2026
Backs: Materials, Departments
- atlanticcigar.com/cigars checked 1 October 2026
Backs: Cigar origins, Products, Brand or store
“Country Of Origin: Nicaragua (2927), Dominican Republic (1295), Honduras (538), Costa Rica (65), USA (60)”
- atlanticcigar.com/contact-us checked 1 October 2026
Backs: Headquarters, Legal entity, Support channels
“601 General Washington Avenue Norristown, PA 19403”
- atlanticcigar.com/international-ordering checked 1 October 2026
Backs: Markets
“Currently orders will only be accepted from Canada, China, Japan, Taiwan, and Malaysia; All U.S. Domestic orders placed before 4:00 PM EST”
- atlanticcigar.com/shipping-returns checked 1 October 2026
Backs: Free shipping threshold, Return window
“UPS Ground Saver: $7.95 Orders Over $99.00 FREE SHIPPING”
Compiled from 6 source pages, checked 1 October 2026. We did not open an account.
